Shopify vs. BigCommerce: BigCommerce is Ultimate Platform Choice for Cost-Conscious, Scalable E-commerce Businesses in 2024

For cost-conscious e-commerce businesses seeking control, scalability, and built-in features, BigCommerce generally meets these needs better than Shopify. Here’s a breakdown based on key priorities:

1. 
   

2. Cost-Conscious and No Transaction Fees:

   • BigCommerce: Stands out as a more affordable option for cost-conscious users. Unlike Shopify, BigCommerce does not charge any transaction fees, regardless of payment gateway, making it ideal for budget-focused businesses.

   • Shopify: Charges transaction fees (1-3%) unless using Shopify Payments, which is restricted to certain countries, increasing costs for businesses in unsupported regions.

3. Shipping Quotes:

   • BigCommerce: Provides real-time shipping quotes on all plans, allowing cost transparency for customers.

   • Shopify: Offers live shipping quotes only on its Advanced and Plus plans and requires third-party integration, increasing costs and setup complexity for lower-tier users.

4. Security:

   • Both Shopify and BigCommerce use 128-bit SSL encryption for customer data security and meet Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards (PCI DSS), ensuring secure transactions on either platform.

5. URL Control:

   • BigCommerce: Allows full customization of URLs, a significant advantage for SEO control. Businesses can tailor URL structures for optimal indexing by search engines.

   • Shopify: Adds preset directories (e.g., /products, /collections) to URLs and does not allow these to be removed, limiting SEO flexibility.

6. Reporting and Analytics:

   • BigCommerce: Provides robust reporting features in all plans, giving access to detailed performance data without extra costs.

   • Shopify: Offers standard reports only on mid-tier plans and advanced reporting on its highest plan, adding costs for full reporting capabilities.

7. Scalability:

   • BigCommerce: Offers built-in features that support scalability without needing extra third-party apps. This reduces potential performance issues and keeps costs predictable.

   • Shopify: Scalable through its vast app store but can increase costs and complexity as businesses rely on third-party integrations for advanced functionality.

   • 
     

Recommendation

For businesses prioritizing cost-efficiency, no transaction fees, URL control, built-in reporting, and scalability without reliance on apps, BigCommerce is the recommended platform. It provides more essential features out-of-the-box, aligns with a cost-conscious approach, and supports SEO-friendly URL control, making it a solid choice for long-term growth.